Surreal editorial illustration of a concrete seesaw with a confident executive and the shadow of an elderly parent in a wheelchair on one side, and a distressed executive on the other, symbolizing the career consequences of revealing caregiving responsibilities.

Welcome to Executive Resilience Insider, where we examine the leadership systems that help organizations make better decisions under pressure.

Today: Why eldercare is a hidden risk for senior leadership teams, how temporary capacity issues get mistaken for poor performance, and what CEOs can do before replacing the wrong person.

 
THE EXECUTIVE DEEP DIVE
 

Every value creation plan I have reviewed lists the top team by name, role, and incentive. None of them lists who is driving a parent to chemotherapy on Thursday.

Each of those people is counted at full strength for the life of the deal.

Most of the time that holds.

When it does not, the gap shows up in a board deck as a performance problem and gets managed like one.

The slowdown that reads as a performance problem

It tends to start small. A CFO who closed the books on day three starts closing on day six. A COO sends a deputy to two operating reviews in one quarter. A sales leader stops flying out to the two accounts that matter most.

Each change has a reasonable explanation on its own, and the operating partner hears the reasonable explanation (a system migration, a deputy who needs exposure, a travel budget under review).

By the third quarter, the pattern is in the board deck, and someone asks whether the CFO is still the right CFO. The CEO starts covering part of the seat personally, at night, without telling the board why the seat needs covering.

Often the cause is a parent two states away, and the company has no field where that could be recorded.

Where the load lands

BLS counted 38.2 million Americans providing unpaid eldercare in 2023 and 2024, 14% of everyone age 15 and up. The likeliest to provide it were people aged 55 to 64, at 24%, and 45 to 54, at 19%, compared with 7.6% of those aged 25 to 34.

MIT Sloan puts the heaviest share on the most experienced employees, senior management included: people in the senior ranks are more than three times as likely as early-career staff to be caring for an elder. KPMG economist Matthew Nestler told MIT Sloan it shows up as a manager who suddenly falls behind, or a director who passes on a promotion.

AARP counts 63 million family caregivers, six in ten of them employed and half of those going in late or leaving early to give care (which is how a day-three close becomes a day-six close).

Harvard Business School surveyed 1,500 employees and 300 HR leaders. It found 52% of employers were not tracking caregiving, and only 24% thought it affected performance, against more than 80% of caregiving employees who said it hurt their output.

A founder running a forty-person firm has the same exposure with less cover. The controller who has been there eleven years starts leaving at three on Tuesdays, and there is no deputy, no operating partner, and no board deck to catch the pattern; the founder finds out at the month-end close.

What the misread costs the person running it

A slower close costs a few days. A wrong diagnosis costs a year.

A CEO who reads a capacity problem as a performance problem opens a performance conversation, then a search. A senior search takes months (longer for a CFO in the middle of a refinancing), and the executive being managed out may have needed three months of cover, not a replacement.

Meanwhile, the CEO carries the seat. Board prep moves to Sunday nights, the numbers get explained twice a quarter, and the operating partner starts asking about the CEO's own bandwidth (a fair question, asked about the wrong person).

And who sits in the same age band as the CFO? Usually the CEO.

The person deciding what the slowdown means is, by the same numbers, about as likely to be managing a parent's care at home, and running the company on whatever is left after it, with the board aware of neither.

Plan for the seat before you need the story

Build a coverage map for the top team this month. For each seat, name who runs it for thirty days with no notice, and what that person would need handed over today to do it.

Leave the reason column off on purpose. The map holds whether the gap is a parent, a surgery, or a resignation, and it requires no disclosure from anyone.

Test one seat a quarter. Have the named cover run a real deliverable (the monthly close, a pipeline review) while the incumbent is still in the building, so the first test is not the emergency.

When a senior executive's output drops after years of steady work, have the capacity conversation before the performance one: what changed in the last six months, and what three months of cover would make possible.

Put a line for interim cover in the operating budget so the answer can be yes without a board vote.

But your own seat goes on the map first.

 

Mario Peshev

EXECUTIVE RESILIENCE INSIDER

Need Clarity On A Decision You're Carrying?

If a senior seat has slowed and you cannot tell capacity from performance, the written brief gets you an outside read first.

Send the question, get a Loom and a two-page memo back inside three days. No call unless you want one.